Even if they were somehow equals, common sense would tilt the scales in Auston Matthews' favor. Scoring is arguably the hardest task in the sport. Besides, if Larkin were remotely close to Matthews' caliber, his paycheck would reflect that reality.
These are the players who command their salaries because they're game-changers. They're capable of shifting a match's outcome singlehandedly. No offense to Larkin, but he doesn't quite inhabit the same realm as these powerhouses.
He even ventured to suggest that the Leafs could've snagged players like Alexander Wennberg ($4.5M), Brandon Saad ($4.5M), Tyson Barrie ($4.5M), or Nikita Zaitsev ($4.5M) with the hypothetical savings. You really can't make this stuff up.